Inicio
todoELE
  • Inicio
  • Materiales
    • 📋 Actividades
    • 📝 Conjugación
    • 📊 Corpus
    • 📔 Diccionarios
    • ✅ Evaluación
    • ⚙️ Gramática
    • 📗 Manuales
    • ✍️ Ortografía
    • 📅 Programación
    • 🗣️ Pronunciación
    • 📁 Recursos
    • 🔤 Vocabulario
    • 💻 Herramientas digitales
  • Formación
    • 📚 Bibliografía
    • 👥 Congresos
    • 🎓 Cursos
    • 🏫 Centros
    • 🏢 Organizaciones
    • 📰 Revistas
    • 🌍 Atlas de ELE
  • Trabajo
    • 💼 Ofertas de trabajo
    • ℹ️ Trabajo - Recursos
  • En la red
    • 🌐 Sitios ELE
    • 📰 Agregador
    • 📧 Formespa
  • IA
    • ✨ Nuevos contenidos
    • 📚 Bibliografía IA
    • 🧰 Herramientas IA
    • 💬 Prompts
    • 🧪 Experiencias IA
    • 🌐 Sitios web IA
    • 📰 Actualidad IA
  • Comunidad
    • 📰 Actualidad ELE
    • 😊 Anécdotas ELE
    • 📝 Blog
    • 📌Tablón de anuncios
  • Buscar

Ruta de navegación

  • Inicio
  • Bibliografia
  • Meta-analysis to estimate the relative effectiveness of TBLT programs: Are we there yet?

Meta-analysis to estimate the relative effectiveness of TBLT programs: Are we there yet?

Frank Boers
Farahnaz Faez
2023
Language Teaching Research
30-3
1525-1543
https://doi.org/10.1177/136216882311675…
artículo
metaanálisis
revisión bibliográfica
enfoque por tareas
enseñanza/aprendizaje de lenguas
enfoques y métodos
metodología de investigación

Bryfonski and McKay published a meta-analytic review of reports on the effectiveness of task-based programs relative to other types of programs. The aggregated effect in support of task-based programs was substantial. However, Boers et al. re-examined the 27 comparative studies from which this effect size was calculated and argued that, with one exception, they did not serve the intended purpose of the meta-analysis well. However, in a recent publication, Xuan et al. argue that a good number of the primary studies used by Bryfonski and McKay are in fact suitable for a meta-analysis if the programs they assess are re-defined as task-supported rather than task-based programs. Xuan et al. then conducted a meta-analysis of 16 of the 27 comparative studies that were originally included in Bryfonski and McKay's analysis, confirming the benefits of programs that use tasks, albeit with a smaller aggregated effect size. The present article revisits these 16 studies and, in addition, examines a handful more recent ones published since Bryfonski and McKay's original meta-analysis. The conclusion remains that the field is not ripe yet for a meaningful meta-analysis of the relative effectiveness of either task-based or task-supported programs. Interpreting the outcomes of the meta-analytic endeavours reported so far is especially difficult because of a lack of clarity in both the primary study reports and the meta-analyses of what constitutes a task-supported program and of what is understood by 'task'.

  • Inicie sesión para enviar comentarios

Enviar publicación

Contenidos relacionados

  • How effective is task-based language teaching to enhance second language learning? A technical comment on Bryfonski and McKay (2019)
  • Psicolingüística y didáctica de las lenguas: una aproximación histórica y conceptual
  • Principios básicos y aplicación del aprendizaje mediante tareas
  • ¿Qué significa trabajar en clase con tareas comunicativas?
  • Nuevos desarrollos y propuestas curriculares. Programar a partir del MCER
  • La enseñanza del francés y el español en Rumanía a partir de 1950: historia y metodología. Del método tradicional a la enseñanza por tareas
Sobre Todoele Índice Publica Contacto: [email protected]
Política de privacidad Créditos